Now this is a property filled with possibilities.
Located in Burley, the former El Buen Samaritano Chapel offers beautiful stained glass windows, vaulted ceilings, and nearly 3,700 square feet of space ready for someone with creativity and vision.
Church conversions continue to grow in popularity, and this charming 1940 chapel could become an absolutely incredible home, event venue, studio, or multi-use property.
The biggest question is: what would you do with it?
A Charming Historic Chapel
Built around 1940, this former church has been exceptionally well maintained and still retains much of its original character and charm.
The exterior has the warm, inviting feel of a classic neighborhood chapel, while the interior features architectural details that immediately stand out.
Highlights include:
- Beautiful stained glass windows
- Vaulted ceilings
- Spacious sanctuary area
- Original architectural character
- Large basement gathering space
- Baseboards and vintage details
- Corner lot location
- Exterior storage building
The stained glass windows alone create an incredible atmosphere, filling the space with colorful natural light throughout the day.
Endless Possibilities for Conversion
The main sanctuary space could easily become one of the most unique great rooms imaginable.
With its soaring ceilings and open layout, the possibilities are almost endless.
Potential ideas include:
- A dramatic open-concept home
- Artist or music studio
- Boutique event venue
- Vacation rental or Airbnb
- Creative co-working space
- Daycare or community space
- Multi-family conversion
The existing layout already includes two possible bedrooms and two bathrooms, while the large basement adds even more usable square footage.
Spacious Basement With Kitchen
One of the most practical features of the property is the expansive basement area.
The lower level includes:
- Large kitchen
- Dining and gathering area
- Two restrooms
- Staircases at both ends
- Flexible open space
The listing even suggests that adding a shower could make the property even more functional as a residence.
This lower level could become an amazing entertainment space, apartment area, recreation room, or additional living quarters.
Property Features
This Idaho chapel includes:
- 2 Bedrooms
- 2 Bathrooms
- 3,678 Square Feet
- Built circa 1940
- Located on a corner lot
Additional perks include gas heat, irrigation access, and zoning flexibility.
According to the listing, the R-2 zoning allows use as:
- Church
- Daycare
- Single-family residence
- Multi-family residence (1–4 units)
That flexibility makes this property especially appealing for buyers looking for a unique investment or live/work opportunity.
What Would You Do With It?
Honestly, this is the kind of property where imagination becomes the biggest factor.
Personally, the sanctuary would make an unbelievable living room with a dramatic chandelier, cozy seating areas, and preserved stained glass as the centerpiece of the home.
The basement could easily become a modern entertaining area with a game room, home theater, guest suite, or even a separate apartment space.
Some buyers might lean fully into the historic chapel aesthetic, while others could create a stunning modern-industrial conversion that blends old and new design elements together.
Either way, properties like this are incredibly rare.
Listing Price
$395,000
Contact Information
Shellien Gilliland
Gem State Realty
Phone: 208-316-8778
Photo Gallery
[Insert Property Photos Here]
Zillow Listing
Paste Zillow property link directly below the photos.
Final Thoughts
Between the beautiful stained glass windows, vaulted ceilings, spacious layout, and flexible zoning, this former Idaho chapel offers an exciting opportunity for the right buyer.
Whether transformed into a one-of-a-kind residence, creative space, or income-producing property, this historic building is filled with potential and personality.
And honestly, those stained glass windows deserve to be preserved and admired for another generation.
