Private Island Retreat with Panoramic Lake Views – 44420 Butterfield, Alexandria Bay, NY 13607 | $339,000
Discover the charm of island living with this 5-bedroom, 1-bath detached home, built in 1895 and set on a private island in the heart of Alexandria Bay. With 1,126 sq ft of rustic yet comfortable interior space and an 8,712 sq ft lot, this unique property offers a rare blend of historic character, modern features, and unmatched water views.
🏡 Interior & Features:
-
Rustic charm with updated touches
-
Two fireplaces, including a dual-sided fireplace that warms both the interior and outdoor deck—perfect for cozy nights or outdoor cooking
-
Fully furnished, including tools, chainsaw, and other equipment for island living
-
Ideal for seasonal use, off-grid getaways, or unique rental potential
🌊 Waterfront & Outdoor Amenities:
-
Panoramic lake views from every angle
-
Full-size dock and additional dock access
-
Includes three boats:
-
15-ft Yamaha (40HP)
-
12-ft Nissan (9.5HP)
-
6HP Johnson outboard motor
-
📊 Property Details:
-
Price: $339,000
-
Zestimate: $313,600 (Range: $298,000–$329,000)
-
Assessed Value: $77,500
-
Annual Taxes: Approx. $1,819
-
Price per Sq Ft: ~$301
Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat, a boater’s paradise, or a truly one-of-a-kind vacation property, this island getaway offers it all.
📞 For more details or to schedule a viewing, please contact the listing agent via the Zillow link below the photos.
Watch Zillow
