Experience a truly unique lifestyle on your very own private island in Alexandria Bay, New York. Built in 1895, this charming lakefront home at 44420 Butterfield Island combines rustic Adirondack character with modern-day comfort. With 5 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and approximately 1,126 square feet of living space, it offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Thousand Islands history in one of Upstate New York’s most breathtaking settings.
A Rare Waterfront Sanctuary
Set on an 8,712-square-foot lot, this private island property provides panoramic water views and the kind of tranquility that’s nearly impossible to find on the mainland. Whether you’re watching the sunrise over the calm waters or enjoying an evening fire under the stars, this retreat is designed for those who love nature, boating, and privacy.
The exterior features two fireplaces, including a dual-sided stone hearth that warms both the cozy living area and the outdoor deck. The outdoor fireplace doubles as a grill—perfect for lakeside barbecues and summer gatherings with friends and family.
Lakefront Access and Boating Amenities
For water lovers, this property delivers the ultimate boating experience. The private waterfront includes a full-size dock and ample space for multiple boats. Included with the property are:
-
A 15-foot Yamaha boat with a 40HP motor
-
A 12-foot Nissan boat with a 9.5HP motor
-
A 6HP Johnson outboard motor, allowing you to attach your own
With these features, you can explore the stunning St. Lawrence River, fish for bass and northern pike, or simply relax as you glide through the Thousand Islands region—right from your backyard.
Interior Features and Island Comfort
Inside, this historic 19th-century home retains its original charm while providing all the essentials for comfortable island living. The warm wood finishes, open layout, and large windows make every room feel inviting and filled with natural light.
The home includes five bedrooms, making it ideal for hosting guests or creating a peaceful family getaway. The main living area features the first of two fireplaces, giving it a cozy cabin feel year-round. The kitchen and dining spaces are functional and ready for everyday use or weekend entertaining.
Move-In Ready and Fully Equipped
The property is offered fully furnished and comes complete with tools, work equipment, and maintenance essentials—including a chainsaw and various supplies—so you can step into island life immediately. Whether you plan to use it as a vacation retreat, Airbnb rental, or full-time residence, the home is set up for comfort, convenience, and independence.
Property Value and Market Information
-
Listing Price: $339,000
-
Zestimate Value: $313,600 (range: $298,000–$329,000)
-
Price per Sq Ft: Approximately $301
-
Assessed Value: $77,500
-
Annual Property Tax: Around $1,819
These figures highlight both the value and investment potential of owning a private island home in a highly desirable location like Alexandria Bay.
A Piece of Thousand Islands History
Butterfield Island is part of the world-famous Thousand Islands region—an area celebrated for its natural beauty, crystal-clear waters, and recreational lifestyle. Residents and visitors enjoy boating, kayaking, swimming, and fishing, along with easy access to local restaurants, marinas, and cultural attractions in Alexandria Bay.
Why This Island Home Stands Out
-
Private island with 360° lake views
-
Fully furnished and ready to move in
-
Two fireplaces, including one outdoor hearth
-
Multiple boats and motors included
-
Full dock system for water access
-
Historic 1895 construction with rustic charm
-
Peaceful, self-sufficient setting yet close to town
This is more than just a property—it’s a lifestyle. The combination of history, waterfront access, and privacy makes 44420 Butterfield Island one of the most special listings in Northern New York.
Interested in learning more or scheduling a private tour?
Please contact the listing agent through the Zillow link provided below the photos for complete details, current availability, and viewing arrangements.
Watch Zillow
